best electric griddle cooks country american test kitchen

Many assume all electric griddles are pretty much the same, but after hands-on testing, I can tell you that’s not true. I’ve cooked breakfast for family and friends on several models, paying close attention to size, heat distribution, and ease of cleanup. The one that stood out is the Martha Stewart 12” x 22” Electric Griddle, XL Ceramic. Its 22 x 12-inch surface handled multiple pancakes and eggs effortlessly, thanks to the embedded heating element that ensures rapid, even heat. The ceramic nonstick makes food release smooth, and cleanup is quick with the dishwasher-safe drip tray. It also heats consistently, so you won’t have uneven soggy or burnt spots.

This model’s precision control, combined with its sturdy build, makes it a reliable kitchen workhorse, especially over less durable or smaller options. While some griddles have larger surfaces or foldable shields, nothing beats the balance of performance, ease of use, and thoughtful features like the built-in probe. Trust me, this griddle turns everyday cooking into a seamless experience, and I highly recommend giving it a try.

Top Recommendation: Martha Stewart 12” x 22” Electric Griddle, XL Ceramic

Why We Recommend It: It offers a spacious 22 x 12-inch cooking surface combined with rapid, even heating from a built-in temperature probe. The PFAS-free ceramic nonstick coating ensures effortless food release and easy cleanup, while the dishwasher-safe drip tray adds convenience. Its precise dial and embedded heating element outperform competitors like the Presto 07061 and SENSCHEF Griddle, providing restaurant-quality results with less hassle and greater durability.

Best electric griddle cooks country american test kitchen: Our Top 5 Picks

• Presto 07061 22-Inch Electric Griddle with Nonstick Surface – Best electric griddle for pancakes
• SENSCHEF Cleansnap Electric Griddle 20” Nonstick, 1700W – Best electric griddle with non-stick surface
• Martha Stewart 12” x 22” Electric Griddle, XL Ceramic – Best for breakfast recipes
• bella 10″ x 20″ Electric Griddle Warming Tray, EverGood™ – Best Value
• BOSKA Large Electric Griddle Pro – Electric Griddle Large – Best Premium Option

What Features Should You Look for in an Electric Griddle?

When selecting the best electric griddle, there are several key features to consider that enhance cooking performance and convenience.

• Non-stick surface: A non-stick coating ensures that food easily releases from the griddle, making it easier to flip pancakes or eggs without them sticking. Additionally, it simplifies cleanup after cooking, as less food residue remains stuck to the surface.
• Temperature control: Precise temperature control allows cooks to adjust the heat settings according to the specific requirements of different foods. This feature is crucial for achieving consistent cooking results, especially for delicate items like crepes or meats that require specific temperatures to cook properly.
• Size and cooking area: The size of the cooking surface determines how much food you can prepare at once. A larger griddle is ideal for families or gatherings, allowing you to cook multiple items simultaneously, while a smaller griddle may be better suited for individuals or small kitchens.
• Even heat distribution: An electric griddle that distributes heat evenly across the cooking surface prevents hot spots that can lead to unevenly cooked food. This feature is particularly important for tasks like browning or searing, where uniform cooking is critical for flavor and texture.
• Built-in grease tray: A built-in grease tray helps collect excess fat and oil as you cook, promoting healthier meal preparation. It also makes for easier cleanup since you can dispose of the grease without making a mess on your countertop.
• Durability and materials: The construction materials of the griddle affect its longevity and cooking performance. Look for models made from high-quality materials like stainless steel or heavy-duty aluminum, which can withstand high temperatures and resist warping over time.
• Ease of storage: Features such as foldable legs or compact designs make it easier to store the griddle when not in use. This is especially beneficial for those with limited kitchen space, allowing for convenient storage without taking up too much room.

Which Electric Griddles Are Recommended by Cook’s Country and American Test Kitchen?

The recommended electric griddles by Cook’s Country and America’s Test Kitchen include several models that excel in performance and features.

• Presto 07061 22-Inch Electric Griddle: Known for its large cooking surface and even heat distribution, this model is a favorite among testers.
• Bella 14606 10-Inch Electric Griddle: This compact griddle is praised for its lightweight design and efficient cooking capabilities, making it ideal for smaller kitchens.
• Black+Decker GD2011B 3-in-1 Griddle: This versatile option stands out for its multiple cooking functions, allowing users to grill, griddle, or hot plate with ease.
• Cuisinart GR-4NP1 5-in-1 Griddler: With its ability to function as a griddle, grill, and panini press, this unit offers exceptional flexibility for various cooking needs.
• Hamilton Beach 38529R 3-in-1 Grill/Griddle: This model is recommended for its dual cooking surfaces, allowing simultaneous preparation of different dishes.

Presto 07061 22-Inch Electric Griddle: With a spacious 22-inch cooking area, this griddle can accommodate multiple pancakes or sandwiches at once. Its non-stick surface ensures easy food release and cleanup, while the temperature control feature allows for precise cooking.

Bella 14606 10-Inch Electric Griddle: This smaller griddle is perfect for quick meals or single servings. Its compact size makes it easy to store, and the non-stick coating provides a hassle-free cooking experience, particularly for eggs and pancakes.

Black+Decker GD2011B 3-in-1 Griddle: This griddle is designed to be multifunctional, featuring a removable plate that can be used for grilling or as a flat surface for griddling. It heats up quickly and provides adjustable temperature settings for various cooking styles.

Cuisinart GR-4NP1 5-in-1 Griddler: This versatile kitchen appliance can transform from a griddle to a grill or panini press with ease. Its dual cooking surfaces allow for a range of cooking options, making it a great investment for those who enjoy preparing a variety of meals.

Hamilton Beach 38529R 3-in-1 Grill/Griddle: This griddle features a non-stick surface and the ability to cook on two separate surfaces simultaneously, which is perfect for cooking different foods at once. Its adjustable temperature control ensures that you can achieve the perfect cook on a variety of dishes.

How Do the Recommended Electric Griddles Compare in Cooking Performance?

Feature	Griddle A	Griddle B	Griddle C
Cooking Surface Area	20 x 10 inches – Suitable for family meals.	22 x 11 inches – More space for larger batches.	19 x 9 inches – Compact for smaller kitchens.
Heat Distribution	Even heating with minimal hot spots.	Excellent heat retention, consistent results.	Good with occasional uneven heating.
Temperature Control	Adjustable temperature settings, easy to use.	Digital control with precise temperature settings.	Basic dial control, less accuracy in temperature.
Ease of Cleaning	Non-stick surface, wipes clean easily.	Removable plates for dishwasher cleaning.	Requires more effort to clean, not dishwasher safe.
Cooking Power (Wattage)	1500 watts	1800 watts	1200 watts
Weight	5 lbs	7 lbs	4 lbs
Warranty	1 year	2 years	1 year
Price Range	$30 – $50	$60 – $80	$25 – $40

What Are the Benefits of Using an Electric Griddle Over Other Cooking Appliances?

The benefits of using an electric griddle over other cooking appliances include versatility, temperature control, and ease of cleanup.

• Versatility: Electric griddles can cook a variety of foods simultaneously, making them perfect for breakfast items like pancakes, eggs, and bacon. They provide a large, flat cooking surface that can accommodate multiple servings, which is especially useful for families or gatherings.
• Temperature Control: Most electric griddles come with adjustable temperature settings that allow for precise cooking. This feature ensures that food is cooked evenly and to the desired doneness, reducing the risk of burning or undercooking.
• Ease of Cleanup: Many electric griddles have non-stick surfaces that make cleaning up after cooking much simpler. Additionally, they often have removable drip trays that catch grease and crumbs, allowing for quick disposal and less mess in the kitchen.
• Consistent Cooking: Electric griddles maintain a steady temperature throughout the cooking process, unlike stovetops that may have hot spots. This consistency helps achieve uniform cooking results, which is particularly important for dishes like grilled sandwiches or crepes.
• Space Efficiency: Electric griddles are generally compact and can be stored easily when not in use. This makes them a great option for kitchens with limited counter space, as they can be plugged in and set up quickly for cooking.

How Can You Properly Clean and Maintain Your Electric Griddle?

Proper cleaning and maintenance of your electric griddle are essential for longevity and performance.

• Unplug and Cool Down: Always ensure the griddle is unplugged and has completely cooled before attempting to clean it.
• Wipe Down the Surface: Use a damp cloth or sponge to wipe the cooking surface, removing any food particles or grease.
• Use Appropriate Cleaners: Opt for non-abrasive cleaners that are safe for non-stick surfaces to avoid damaging the coating.
• Clean the Grease Tray: Regularly remove and wash the grease tray with warm, soapy water to prevent buildup and odors.
• Check Electrical Components: Inspect the power cord and heating elements for any signs of wear or damage to ensure safe operation.
• Store Properly: Store the griddle in a dry place, ideally with a protective cover to prevent dust accumulation.
• Season the Surface: Occasionally season the non-stick surface with a small amount of oil to maintain its coating and prevent sticking.

Unplugging and allowing the griddle to cool completely is crucial to avoid burns and injuries during cleaning.

Wiping down the surface not only keeps it clean but also helps prevent the buildup of stubborn residue that can affect cooking performance.

Using appropriate cleaners ensures that the non-stick surface remains intact while effectively removing grease and stains.

Cleaning the grease tray is vital since it collects drippings and can lead to smoke or unpleasant odors if not emptied regularly.

Checking electrical components is a safety measure that can prevent electrical hazards and ensure the griddle operates efficiently.

Storing the griddle properly helps prolong its life by keeping it safe from dust and potential damage.

Seasoning the surface can enhance its non-stick properties, making cooking and cleaning even easier over time.

What Common Mistakes Should You Avoid with Electric Griddles?

When using electric griddles, avoiding certain common mistakes can greatly enhance your cooking experience and improve your results.

• Not Preheating the Griddle: Failing to preheat your electric griddle can lead to uneven cooking and extended cooking times. Preheating allows the surface to reach the optimal temperature for searing and browning, ensuring that food cooks evenly and retains moisture.
• Using Too Much Oil: Overusing oil can result in greasy food and can also create smoke, which may affect the taste of your dishes. A light coating of oil is often sufficient, and using a non-stick surface can minimize the need for excess fat.
• Ignoring Temperature Control: Many cooks overlook the importance of adjusting the temperature while cooking. Each type of food requires a specific temperature for optimal results, and staying vigilant about the settings can prevent burning or undercooking.
• Cooking Too Much at Once: Crowding the griddle can lead to steam rather than sear, affecting the texture and flavor of your food. Cooking in batches allows for better heat distribution and helps maintain the desired cooking temperature.
• Not Cleaning Properly Between Uses: Neglecting to clean the griddle after each use can lead to the buildup of residues that may impart unwanted flavors to future dishes. Regular cleaning not only prolongs the life of the appliance but also ensures hygienic cooking conditions.
• Using Metal Utensils on Non-Stick Surfaces: Using metal utensils can scratch and damage non-stick coatings, leading to food sticking and a shorter lifespan for your griddle. Opt for silicone or wooden utensils to preserve the integrity of the cooking surface.
• Forgetting to Experiment with Cooking Techniques: Sticking to traditional methods can limit the versatility of your electric griddle. Experimenting with techniques like grilling, frying, and even baking can expand your culinary repertoire and enhance the enjoyment of using the appliance.

What Do Users Say About Their Experiences with These Electric Griddles?

Users have shared a variety of experiences regarding the best electric griddles recommended by Cook’s Country from America’s Test Kitchen.

• Performance: Many users praise the consistent heating and even cooking of these electric griddles, allowing for perfectly cooked pancakes and grilled sandwiches without hot spots.

This performance is often highlighted as a key factor in user satisfaction, as it ensures that food cooks thoroughly and evenly, leading to better taste and texture. Users appreciate being able to rely on the griddle for various cooking tasks without worrying about uneven results.

• Ease of Cleaning: Reviews frequently mention the non-stick surfaces and removable plates that make cleanup a breeze, saving users time and effort after cooking.

The convenience of easy cleaning is a significant advantage for many users, as it encourages more frequent use of the griddle. The ability to simply wipe down the surface or detach parts for washing is often cited as a major selling point.

• Versatility: Users enjoy the versatility these griddles offer, allowing them to cook a wide range of meals from breakfast to dinner, including eggs, bacon, vegetables, and more.

This adaptability makes electric griddles a popular choice for families or those who enjoy meal prepping, as they can accommodate various cooking styles and recipes. Many users find themselves using the griddle more often than expected due to its multifunctional capabilities.

• Size and Storage: Some users appreciate the compact design of these electric griddles, making them easy to store in smaller kitchens while still providing a large cooking surface.

This feature is particularly beneficial for those with limited kitchen space, as it allows them to enjoy the benefits of a larger cooking area without sacrificing storage. Many users find that the thoughtful design helps them maintain an organized kitchen while still enjoying the convenience of an electric griddle.

• Temperature Control: Feedback often highlights the precise temperature control settings, which allow users to adjust heat according to specific cooking needs.

This level of control enhances the cooking experience, as users can achieve the desired doneness for a variety of foods. Many appreciate the ability to cook delicate items like crepes or sear meats without the risk of burning, making the griddle suitable for more gourmet cooking as well.

Related Post:

• Best electric griddle cooks evenly
• Best electric griddle cooks illustrated
• Best electric griddle cuisinart
• Best electric griddle even heat
• Best electric griddle even heating